Tonight they are going to evict Occupy L.A. from in front of the City Hall building. My wife and I are sitting here watching the live telecast, and hearing the helicopters overhead. I have largely kept my opinions to myself concerning this movement, but I feel that I need to say something especially since it’s coming to a crescendo here tonight.
First of all, I feel for the movement, because I am no where near the 1%, and am solidly within the 99%. There is something wrong with society when the rich keep getting richer and the poor, poorer. I think whether we realize it or not, deep down, we all long for Jubilee. We long for that day when debts will be forgiven, when slaves will be set free, when wealth will be redistributed, and so on. As someone, shackled with tens of thousands of dollars in debt (from seminary, no less) these principles resonate with me.
Justice is something that we all long for. We yearn for it with every fabric of our being because things are not as they should be.
However, I don’t believe that this movement has been all that effective:
1) There is no unifying cause – Everyone that the newscasters have been interviewing has their own version of why they are occupying. There really is no unifying principle. What is it that they want? I agree that we need systemic changes, but unfortunately that requires the 1%. It requires 100% of the people, rich and poor, coming together to change the system from within. But it also requires knowing what that change needs to be and then to tackle that. I see this as the biggest weakness of this movement. Numbers mean nothing without direction, vision, mission, goals.
2) We are all to blame – These things didn’t occur overnight. We didn’t just wake up one day to find politicians in the hands of special interest groups and lobbyists. We allowed this to happen. It’s funny, but when things are fine, when everyone’s doing well, gainfully employed, and able to spend at will, no one complains, no one protests. But when the economy is bad, everyone else is to blame except ourselves. I’m sorry, but it’s not the banks, it’s not the Fed, it’s not even politicians (although I personally think the needle points in their favor…), it’s not Obama and his administration. We are all culpable for what has happened, and we must all face the consequences of our actions, of our corporate (collective; not Corporate) greed.
3) Ironically costing everyone more – The money spent on extra police presence is in the millions, and for some it’s preventing them from getting to work. If you aren’t working, you aren’t paying taxes. Therefore, we who pay taxes are funding them to occupy, and I don’t think that everyone has agreed to let them do so…
4) The movement is not representative of everyone – Where are all of the Asians? I just have to ask that, because the movement is largely a white movement. The typical occupier is a white male. It’s misleading then, because the movement is not representative of the whole 99%. Do these people even vote? If historical polling numbers are any indication, then the answer has to be “no.”
These are just some of the things that I see as major concerns/objections I have with this movement. I realize that things are not good right now, and probably won’t be good for a long time. But in this life we will have trouble, as Jesus warned. Things unfortunately will not be set right–fully–on this side of Christ’s return. That doesn’t mean that we stop trying, stop obeying, stop loving, stop championing for justice.
The reality is though that no matter how hard we protest, sin is something that cannot be defeated in our own strength. No matter how loud we shout, ultimately people are selfish and will naturally lean in that direction: greed begets greed. But thankfully, Jesus showed us another way to be human, the true way to be human, and that can only come in and through Him.
We must be occupied by Him.
This is a message that is very clear.
Like this:
Be the first to like this post.